Imagine you go in for a routine procedure, such as a gallbladder removal. Instead, you wake up to learn the wrong organ was removed. It sounds like a plot from a medical drama, but it is not. It is a real, documented category of medical error known as a surgical error.
The question you immediately ask is: Can you sue? The answer, in almost every case, is yes. Wrong-site and wrong-patient surgeries are so far outside the bounds of acceptable medical care that regulators classify them as “never events,” errors that basic verification protocols should prevent. Florida law gives you powerful tools to hold surgeons and hospitals accountable.
At James Horne Law P.A., we handle serious malpractice claims, including wrong-site and wrong-patient surgeries, across Southwest Florida and the Tampa Bay region. If you or a loved one were harmed by a surgical mistake that should never have happened, we investigate, work with medical experts, and fight for fair compensation for you.
What Actually Counts as a Wrong-Site or Wrong-Patient Error?
These two error types get lumped together in casual conversation, but they are legally distinct.
Wrong-Site
Wrong-site surgery happens when a surgeon operates on the correct patient but at the wrong location. This can mean the wrong side of the body, such as where a surgeon operated on the wrong side of a patient’s pelvic area, removing healthy tissue while the cancerous lesion remained untouched on the opposite side. Other times, it means the wrong body site entirely.
Wrong-Patient
Wrong-patient surgery malpractice is a different and arguably more disturbing failure. It means the wrong person is brought into the operating room for a procedure they were never supposed to have. There’s also a related category: wrong procedure, where the correct patient and site are used, but the wrong operation is performed.
Never Events
All three are considered “never events.” These are not the kind of complications that arise with proper care. Hospitals have developed safeguards like site-marking, protocols where the surgeon signs the correct location on the patient’s body before the procedure, and a required “timeout” before surgery, where the team confirms the patient, procedure, and site.
How Do These Mistakes Actually Happen?
Wrong-site or wrong-patient surgeries often result from a chain of smaller failures, including:
- A rushed or incomplete surgical timeout,
- A chart that was not double-checked,
- Mislabeled imaging,
- Incomplete consent forms, or
- Two patients with the same name are scheduled for surgery on the same day.
Even hospitals with required safety protocols can have these errors if the surgical team’s coordination breaks down. The Agency for Health Care Research and Quality estimates that surgical errors occur in roughly 1 out of every 112,000 hospital OR procedures, with a likely higher rate in outpatient settings.
A recent Florida case illustrates how catastrophic these mistakes can be. In August 2024, 70-year-old William Bryan went in for a routine splenectomy, the removal of the spleen. But the surgeon, who had a history of similar mistakes, removed his liver instead, resulting in Bryan’s death. This example shows exactly the pattern a surgical malpractice attorney looks for: a preventable identification failure and a hospital system that failed to intervene before real harm occurred.
Proving a Breach of the Standard of Care in These Cases
Under Florida law, a plaintiff generally must prove that the healthcare provider fell below the acceptable standard of care. In most malpractice cases, the fight is between competing medical experts over what a “reasonable” doctor would have done, since two competent physicians can reasonably disagree about the right treatment choice.
Wrong-site and wrong-patient surgeries are different because there is no legitimate professional disagreement about which side has the tumor or which patient is scheduled for the procedure. There is one correct answer, already documented in the chart, the consent form, and the imaging before the patient ever reaches the operating room.
Florida is not, on its face, generous to patients; the mere fact that you suffered a medical injury does not, by itself, create a presumption of negligence. Wrong-site and wrong-patient errors fall under a doctrine Florida courts call res ipsa loquitur, “the thing speaks for itself.” It applies when an injury is the kind that simply would not have happened if the surgical team had exercised proper care. A patient who wakes up to learn the wrong organ was removed, or that the wrong side was operated on, fits that description.
Res ipsa loquitur allows the jury to infer that a breach of the standard of care occurred and shifts the burden to the defendant to explain, but the plaintiff does not automatically win on that basis alone. Investigation and expert testimony are still needed to establish causation, the extent of damages, or how liability is divided among the surgeon, hospital, and staff when more than one party may be responsible.
What Are Florida’s Filing Rules?
Florida imposes strict procedural steps before a medical malpractice case, including surgical error claims, can be filed. You must send the healthcare provider a formal notice of intent to sue and go through a 90-day presuit investigation period, supported by a corroborating affidavit from a qualifying medical expert. Skipping this step can result in a case being dismissed regardless of its merits, which is one of the biggest reasons to involve counsel early rather than wait.
Timing matters just as much. You generally have two years from when the injury was discovered, or should reasonably have been discovered, to file a medical malpractice claim, subject to an outer statute of repose.
What Types of Compensation Can You Recover?
Compensation in a Florida surgical error case generally falls into two categories.
Economic damages cover losses that have a paper trail. These typically include:
- Hospital and surgical bills, including any emergency care or corrective procedures made necessary by the error;
- Diagnostic imaging and testing used to identify or monitor the resulting harm;
- Medications, medical equipment, and adaptive devices needed for recovery or to manage a new condition;
- Rehabilitation and physical therapy aimed at restoring function or mobility;
- In-home or long-term nursing care, when the injury requires ongoing support; and
- Lost wages and reduced future earning capacity if the injury affects your ability to work.
Florida places no statutory cap on economic damages in a medical malpractice case, so a jury or settlement can account for the full, documented financial impact.
Noneconomic damages are typically harder to measure because there are no receipts. These typically include:
- Physical pain that affects daily comfort, mobility, sleep, and routine functioning;
- Emotional distress, anxiety, and the psychological toll of the injury and its treatment;
- Scarring or disfigurement;
- Loss of enjoyment of life; and
- Loss of consortium for a spouse.
Although Florida’s statute still lists dollar caps on noneconomic damages on paper, those caps are no longer enforced. The Florida Supreme Court struck them down as unconstitutional, first for wrongful death claims in 2014, then extended that holding to personal injury malpractice cases in 2017.
Wrongful Death Cases and Florida’s “Free Kill” Law
If a surgical error results in a patient’s death, the current “Free Kill” law bars adult children and parents of a deceased adult patient from recovering noneconomic damages in a wrongful death medical malpractice case, unless the deceased left behind a spouse or minor children. The law has faced repeal and veto efforts in the past few years. As of now, the restriction remains in effect, though the fight in Tallahassee continues, and the outcome for future cases is genuinely uncertain.
What to Do Next
Wrong-site and wrong-patient surgical errors are rare, but when they happen, the damage is severe, and the legal path forward is comparatively clear. Florida law does not automatically treat these never events as proof of negligence. However, injured patients have real tools and avenues to recover compensation for medical bills, lost income, and pain and suffering. A never-event lawsuit also requires a structured presuit process that a lawyer should be handling on your behalf from day one.
At James Horne Law P.A., we understand that medical malpractice cases can be overwhelming. The medical field itself is confusing, the trust you place in your surgeon and hospital has been violated, and you’re in the middle of your own recovery. We take the time to understand the full weight of what happened to you and your family, working with our own team of medical professionals to dig into the record, and preparing every case as if it is going to trial.
We handle these cases on a contingency fee basis, meaning we advance the cost of investigating and building your case, and we only get paid a percentage of what we recover for you. If we don’t win, you owe us nothing. If you believe you or a family member suffered harm from a surgical error, contact James Horne Law P.A. today for a free consultation.
Legal References Used to Inform This Page
To ensure the accuracy and clarity of this page, we referenced official legal and other resources during the content development process:
- Medical negligence; standards of recovery; expert witness, Fla. Stat. § 776.102 (2026).
- Notice before filing action for medical negligence, Fla. Stat. § 776.106 (2026).
- Limitations other than for the recovery of real property, Fla. Stat. § 95.11(5)(c) (2026).
- Damages “Free Kill Law”, Fla. Stat. § 768.21(8) (2026).
- Marrero v. Goldsmith, 486 So. 2d 530 (Fla. 1986).
- Estate of McCall v. United States, 134 So. 3d 894 (Fla. 2014).
- North Broward Hospital District v. Kalitan, 219 So. 3d 49 (Fla. 2017).
- Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, Wrong-Site, Wrong-Procedure, and Wrong-Patient Surgery (Dec. 15, 2024).
- NBC News, Florida surgeon who removed wrong organ says he is ‘forever traumatized’ by patient’s death, By Elizabeth Chuck and Matt Lavietes, (May 7, 2026).
- NBC News, Florida doctor charged in death of patient who had wrong organ removed during surgery, Danielle Abreu (April 14, 2026).

