There are many things to love about living in Florida, from its beaches and wildlife reserves to its metropolitan areas and nightlife. With plenty of sunshine and warm temperatures that allow for outdoor activities even during winter, Florida offers something that many people in other states envy. However, any Floridian who has spent significant time in the Sunshine State knows that we can experience some extreme weather conditions, including thunderstorms, heavy rainfall, and hurricanes. But when someone is injured due to someone else’s negligence, how do weather conditions and personal injury claims affect recovery?
Motor Vehicle Accident Liability in Bad Weather
Adverse weather conditions can cause or contribute to car accidents in many different ways, but it is important to remember that as a driver, you have a duty to be prepared and act with ordinary prudence when dealing with dangerous weather conditions. When a driver fails to behave in a reasonable manner and causes an accident as a result, they can be held responsible for any injuries suffered by the injured party.
What is reasonable differs depending on the specific weather conditions. For example, while it’s reasonable to drive the speed limit on a sunny day, it may be unreasonable to drive the speed limit during a thunderstorm. Similarly, having your headlights on is reasonable when there is thick fog but not necessary when it’s clear.
Bad Weather Does Not Always Mean No One Is Responsible.
Rain, fog, wind, standing water, and storm debris can complicate a personal injury claim. The key is showing whether another driver, property owner, or business failed to act reasonably under the conditions.
Quick claim check
Weather may explain why an accident happened, but it does not automatically excuse unsafe driving, poor maintenance, ignored hazards, or failure to warn about dangerous conditions.
Rain & Wet Roads
Speeding, tailgating, hydroplaning, and failing to slow down for standing water can still support a negligence claim.
Fog or Low Visibility
Drivers may need to use lights, reduce speed, increase distance, and avoid sudden lane changes when visibility is poor.
Storm Debris
Fallen branches, loose signs, unsafe construction items, or poorly maintained trees may raise property owner or business liability issues.
Slippery Property
Wet floors, leaking roofs, poor drainage, and missing warning signs can matter in slip and fall or premises liability claims.
What Evidence Helps in a Weather-Related Injury Claim?
Photos of the scene
Take photos of standing water, storm debris, road conditions, skid marks, traffic signals, damaged property, poor lighting, warning signs, or lack of warning signs.
Weather reports and radar screenshots
Save screenshots of the weather at the exact time and location of the accident. Rain totals, wind speed, visibility, and storm warnings can help explain what conditions existed.
Video footage
Dashcam, traffic camera, business security camera, doorbell camera, or parking lot footage may show how the accident happened before conditions changed.
Witness information
Witnesses can confirm whether another driver was speeding, following too closely, failed to use lights, ignored hazards, or lost control before impact.
Maintenance and inspection records
In premises cases, records may show whether a property owner knew about poor drainage, roof leaks, unsafe walkways, loose mats, falling branches, or other recurring hazards.
Helpful Records to Keep
- Photos and videos of the accident scene
- Weather reports, radar screenshots, and storm alerts
- Police report or incident report number
- Witness names and contact information
- Medical records, bills, and treatment notes
- Repair estimates, towing records, and insurance letters
Mistakes to Avoid
- Do not assume weather makes the claim impossible
- Do not wait too long to photograph the scene
- Do not admit fault because the road was wet
- Do not ignore nearby cameras or witnesses
- Do not give a recorded statement without preparation
- Do not let the insurer blame the storm without proof
Was Weather Used to Blame You for an Accident?
James Horne Law can review the crash facts, weather evidence, insurance position, and liability issues to help protect your Florida injury claim.
Legal Defenses for Negligence in Bad Weather
There are certain defenses that can affect liability in bad weather accidents. If you are in an auto accident in dangerous weather, you may find yourself in a situation where an insurance adjuster or the other party denies your claim by citing one of these defenses.
Sudden emergency
Sometimes, there’s no way to avoid emergencies, even when you are used to Florida’s wild weather. To assert this defense, a party must show:
- A verifiable emergency took place,
- The defendant did not create the emergency,
- The defendant was presented with multiple options to act, and
- A reasonable driver in a similar situation would have a similar outcome.
Florida’s weather can change without notice. One second you’re driving on dry pavement, and the next you’re navigating an afternoon downpour. This defense often hinges on whether the emergency was foreseeable. Random storms happen, but it is easier to predict danger ahead when driving into the heart of a hurricane.
Acts of God
In Florida law, an act of God refers to an event that is out of human control for which no human can be held legally responsible. This includes tornadoes, flash floods, hurricanes, and other natural disasters. If the events, however horrible they may be, were not a product of human action, a human cannot be held legally liable. This defense can be difficult to use in auto accident cases, but sometimes extreme weather events warrant it. For example, if a flash of lightning knocks down a tree and suddenly causes an accident with another vehicle, the driver may not be held liable as the event was out of the driver’s control.
Premises Liability in Bad Weather Conditions
Inclement weather can impact premises liability claims, as well. Humans can’t control the weather, and sometimes a property owner can’t do anything to prevent a weather event from causing danger or injury. For example, if someone slips and falls on asphalt while outdoors, there may not be much the owner can do to remove the danger. To prove a premises liability claim, a plaintiff must show:
- The property owner owed a duty of care,
- They breached their duty, and
- The breach caused you to suffer injuries and actual damage.
To succeed on a premises liability claim where bad weather is involved, you will need to show that the owner was aware of the danger presented by the weather and could have taken reasonable precautions to reduce that danger. For example, if an owner did not take reasonable steps to keep their trees trimmed and a branch fell and hit someone during a windstorm, the owner could be held responsible.
Protecting Your Rights in a Bad Weather Personal Injury Claim
In the aftermath of an accident, it is easy to be overwhelmed by all kinds of stressors, especially if you or a loved one is injured or worse. While evidence is vital to any personal injury claim, having strong evidence is critical after an inclement weather accident. Sometimes storms can pass in a day or even hours. If you are able, gather as much evidence as you can. This establishes the exact weather conditions at the time of the accident and shows how they may have affected the other party’s behavior and your subsequent damages. Evidence that you should collect for your bad weather personal injury claim includes:
- Photos and videos of the weather conditions and accident scene,
- Photos and videos of vehicle and other property damage,
- Witness statements,
- Expert witness reports,
- Weather reports, and
- Cell phone records.
The most important thing after an accident involving bad weather conditions is to ensure your safety. If you have questions about evidence you should gather for an insurance claim or a possible civil case, seek the advice of a Florida personal injury attorney as soon as you can.
Possible Damages in a Florida Personal Injury Case
If you were injured in a bad weather accident and believe another party was negligent, you may be entitled to damages. In Florida, plaintiffs can seek compensation for losses such as lost wages, medical bills, future medical costs, pain and suffering, and more. Under Florida law, some plaintiffs may be able to seek punitive damages as well. These are designed to discourage wrongdoers from intentionally acting in the same or similar manner that led to the injury.
Contact Us
If you have questions about weather conditions and personal injury claims or have been injured in an accident where inclement weather is involved, don’t handle the aftermath alone. James “Jay” Horne is an AV-Preeminent litigation attorney with a track record of success for his clients. He approaches each case as unique and devotes his full attention to each client, no matter the size of the claim. To talk about your case, call our office to set up an appointment, or fill out our online contact form to get started.
FAQs
Who is at fault for a car accident in the rain in Florida?
Often the driver who failed to adjust to the conditions. Florida expects drivers to slow down, increase following distance, and use headlights in bad weather, and one who does not can be held responsible even when rain was a factor.
Can weather be used as a defense to avoid liability?
Sometimes, through the “sudden emergency” or “act of God” defenses, but these are narrow. They generally apply only to truly unforeseeable events the driver did not cause and could not avoid, not ordinary rain.
What if I was partly at fault because of the weather?
You can still recover if you were 50 percent or less at fault, under Florida’s comparative negligence rule, though your compensation is reduced by your share of fault.
Who pays my medical bills after a weather-related crash?
Your PIP coverage pays first regardless of fault, and you can pursue the at-fault driver for additional compensation if your injuries are serious.
What evidence helps a bad-weather accident claim?
Photos and video of the conditions and scene, the crash report, weather reports for that time and place, witness statements, and any dashcam footage. Because storms pass quickly, gathering this early is critical.
How long do I have to file a claim in Florida?
Generally two years from the date of the accident for most crashes occurring after March 2023.
James “Jay” Horne is an AV-Preeminent rated aggressive litigation attorney, who focuses his practice on medical malpractice, personal injury and family law matters. He has successfully represented clients from case inception through trial and appeals in state and federal court. Jay was born and raised on the Suncoast. He is married and proud father to a one year old son. In his free time, he enjoys traveling, golfing and distance running during the cool months.
Loading...