| Read Time: 6 minutes | Category Name

You went to the hospital hoping to get well, not to end up with new injuries. Trying to figure out what went wrong, you unfortunately can’t get anyone on the other end of the phone with answers. Now you want to know if you can hold the hospital accountable for a missed test, surgical error, delayed treatment, or another mistake. Before deciding on next steps, you need accurate information about your rights.

Under Florida law, you can sue a medical provider for malpractice, and in some cases can even sue the hospital. But if you were injured in a public, county, or state-run hospital, you must determine whether sovereign immunity applies and how it affects your claim.

At James Horne Law PA, we can analyze whether suing a government hospital in Florida makes sense in your case. We provide compassionate representation to injured patients and their families.

When Can You Sue a Public or Government Hospital for Medical Malpractice?

You can sue a hospital for medical malpractice if you can show the hospital has a legal basis for liability. The fact that you or a loved one was injured at the hospital is not conclusive proof that the hospital is to blame.

Generally, you can bring a malpractice claim against a medical provider for breaching the prevailing professional standard of care when they cause injuries. Doctors, nurses, radiologists, and others might be liable for delaying treatment or misreading test results. Surgeons and anesthesiologists can make mistakes in the operating room.

But when can you sue the hospital?

A hospital might be liable in two situations: either it employs the person who committed malpractice, or it was itself negligent.

Negligence Committed by a Hospital Employee

Public hospitals in Florida employ thousands of medical professionals, including staff physicians, nurses, radiologists, technicians, and more. Under Florida law, an employer is “vicariously liable” when its employee commits malpractice within the scope of employment.

However, not all doctors or surgeons are hospital employees in Florida. A surgeon might have a contract with a public hospital and admitting privileges, but that doesn’t make them an employee. If you are injured in surgery, your surgeon might be liable for malpractice even if the hospital is not.

As an injured patient, you probably can’t tell what type of arrangement the doctor or surgeon has with the hospital. You aren’t expected to figure out this information on your own. Contact our office. We can investigate the legal nature of the relationship.

Negligence by the Hospital

Under Florida law, a public hospital may be directly liable for negligence. Hospitals have duties to ensure comprehensive risk management and to employ competent staff. Some duties include:

  • Adopt written procedures for selecting staff;
  • Periodically review the treatment provided by staff to patients;
  • Adopt a comprehensive risk management system that meets legal requirements; and
  • Ensure compliance with the hospital’s risk management program.

The hospital could be liable for your injuries if it breached one of these duties. For example, a hospital might receive complaints that your nurse has not been providing appropriate treatment. If the hospital fails to investigate those complaints, you could have a direct claim against the hospital.

How Does Sovereign Immunity Affect Medical Malpractice Claims in Florida?

Sovereign immunity is a legal doctrine that prevents the government from being sued without its consent. The doctrine originated in England. The King, as sovereign, was immune from lawsuits. The American colonies adopted the concept, with the state government as the “sovereign” shielded from lawsuits.

You generally can’t sue the state of Florida or one of its agencies. Sovereign immunity may also protect government-owned or government-operated hospitals and their employees, depending on their legal status and the circumstances. If you are hurt in a government hospital, then sovereign immunity could complicate your legal claim.

Florida has waived sovereign immunity in limited situations. Under Florida law, you can sue the state or one of its agencies or subdivisions for any property damage, personal injury, or death caused by one of its employees acting within the scope of employment. The government is liable to the same extent that a private citizen would be under the law.

In plain terms, you can bring a claim against a public hospital if it or one of its employees injured you by committing medical malpractice. However, the waiver comes with strings. You must provide the government with written notice, and the state caps the amount of compensation you can receive.

Suing a Government Hospital in Florida: What Steps Are Involved?

Your medical malpractice case will likely follow this sequence:

  1. Presuit investigation. You must investigate to determine whether you have reasonable grounds to bring a malpractice claim against the hospital. A key part of the investigation is a medical review from a qualified medical expert, who can provide the required verified written medical expert opinion.
  2. Notice to the government. Florida requires that you provide written notice of your claim to the appropriate agency and, in most cases, the Department of Financial Services. You generally have three years from the day your claim accrues to provide the notice, but only two years if a family member dies from the malpractice.
  3. Presuit discovery. Florida law requires sharing some medical information up front, including access to your medical records. You can also request evidence from the hospital.
  4. Negotiation. The state might open negotiations after performing its own investigation. The aim is to settle the claim without going to trial.
  5. Initiation of a lawsuit. You cannot immediately rush to court to file a lawsuit against a government hospital. Instead, you must wait to file a medical malpractice claim until the agency issues a final determination on your claim or 90 days have passed without a decision, while also complying with Florida’s separate medical malpractice presuit requirements.
  6. Mediation. Florida law requires mediation within 120 days of filing a lawsuit, unless you have agreed to binding arbitration or the parties agree to extend the mediation deadline. Mediation can help nudge you and the hospital toward a settlement.
  7. Trial. A malpractice trial typically involves medical expert witness testimony, as well as testimony about your injuries. Florida courts are busy, so you could wait a year or longer before having your day in court.

Florida medical malpractice claims generally must be filed within two years of the incident or when it was discovered or reasonably should have been discovered, subject to a separate statute of repose and limited exceptions. The government notice requirements do not eliminate these deadlines. An attorney should review both sets of requirements as early as possible.

Each case moves at its own pace, and the above is only a general summary of the steps involved. Contact our firm for individualized assessment of your case.

Does Florida Cap Medical Malpractice Compensation Against a Public Hospital?

Yes, the current cap is $200,000 per person for claims subject to Florida’s sovereign immunity limits. This is generally the maximum the government can be required to pay without additional legislative authorization or an applicable exception, even if the person’s damages exceed that amount.

There is a second cap: the state will not generally pay more than $300,000 when all claims arising from the same incident or occurrence are combined. This limit can matter when multiple people have claims arising from the same incident, including claims involving an injured patient and family members.

The law does allow payment above the statutory limits through a legislative claims bill or, in certain circumstances, a settlement within available insurance coverage. However, payment above those limits is not guaranteed.

These damage caps might seem unfair. Catastrophic injuries can leave you with lifelong disabilities and ongoing medical needs. Paralysis and severe brain injuries could cost millions of dollars. However, seeking accountability from a hospital is nearly as important as the compensation you receive.

Can You Sue an Employee at the Public Hospital?

Generally, government employees acting within the scope of their employment are protected from personal liability. In those circumstances, the claim is usually brought against the government entity rather than the individual employee.

There are exceptions to immunity if the worker acts in bad faith, with malicious purpose, or with wanton and willful disregard for your safety or rights. For example, you might sue a nurse personally if she intentionally injured you. A medical professional who is not a government employee or agent may face personal liability under different rules.

Why Does Acting Early Matter in a Malpractice Case?

You should contact a medical malpractice lawyer as soon as you suspect something is wrong. Early intervention is critical to:

  • Preserve evidence related to your claim, including medical records and your memories of your treatment;
  • Investigate whether a hospital is liable for your injuries;
  • Meet deadlines, including required government notification deadlines to protect your rights;
  • Preserve receipts and bills to prove medical expenses and other economic damages;
  • Document pain, suffering, disability, inconvenience, and mental anguish; and
  • Begin building a legal claim for compensation.

An attorney can help determine whether the hospital is protected by sovereign immunity, identify the applicable notice and filing deadlines, and begin gathering the evidence needed to support your claim. Taking these steps early can help you avoid procedural mistakes that could prevent your case from moving forward.

Speak with James Horne Law PA Today

If it feels like no one has answers about what went wrong at the hospital, contact James Horne Law PA. You can schedule a free consultation to discuss the care you received in a public hospital and your injuries. We can analyze the interplay of sovereign immunity and medical malpractice in Florida, as well as how this doctrine might impact your case.

Our clients are like family, and your case will receive the individual attention it deserves.

Legal References Used to Inform This Page

To ensure the accuracy and clarity of this page, we referenced official legal and other resources during the content development process:

Author Photo

James “Jay” Horne is an AV-Preeminent rated aggressive litigation attorney, who focuses his practice on medical malpractice, personal injury and family law matters. He has successfully represented clients from case inception through trial and appeals in state and federal court. Jay was born and raised on the Suncoast. He is married and proud father to a one year old son. In his free time, he enjoys traveling, golfing and distance running during the cool months.